Thanks so much for submitting this essay to our collection, Joshua – it is an absolutely necessary and vital addition to a group of esays that, like much Wallace criticism, tends to focus on Infinite Jest perhaps a bit more than it should!
My main suggestions are conceptual, though there are a few sentences I’ve flagged as confusing, possibly in need of edits.
I feel that the concept of oblivion is a good way into thinking about Wallace’s hyperconscious writing style, but I feel as if you don’t fully develop the concept. In particular, as I indicate in comments below, the precise nature and fuction of oblivion seems to shift. For Nietzsche, oblivion is a necessary faculty, part of what it means to be human, what allows our nobler forms of consciousness to emerge. Having a damaged oblivion-faculty theatens to drown us in an ocean of irrelevant and paralyzing detail. For Wallace, by contrast, oblivion is a sort of conditioned reflex, a way of avoiding life’s hard truths; paradoxically, confronting life’s hard truths tends to leave one depressed and dread-filled and suicidal. I think you need to highlight these different views of oblivion somewhere in your paper. There are clear links, but they get buried.
There are also some problems with transitions later in the essay, where you segue from Wallace’s views of Nietzsche to Wallace’s modernism/postmodernism. See below.
Finally, I think you need to recalibrate the way you speak about Wallace’s ouvre as a whole to account for the fact that this essay will appear an an essay where many of the framing statements you make about Wallace will already be very familiar to your readers. I.e. turn this from a journal article into something that reads more like a book chapter. Part of that audience-consciousness might involve mentioning the fact that Wallace wrote a book called Oblivion.
No comments:
Post a Comment