worked up the nerve to go through the revision comments from JP tonight. they're just from the introductory chapter and the hughes chapter. a couple things struck me.
1) the guy is really smart. and i say that not in some sycophantic way, but because of the questions he raises. he forces me to consider things that i hadn't thought of. or, he forces me to consider several / many things...
2) he has a deft touch with his criticism. he had pointed critiques to be sure (one, e.g., came in the letter he wrote to me about the hughes chapter where he said he was "unconvinced" of my claim, which normally would have undone my self-consciously fragile psyche, etc.). he does what i think all good teachers should do -- he prods and pushes for self-exploration. he asks questions rather than makes declarations. and when he does make declarations, he adds a paragraph or two of explanation. near and dear to my own educational heart, he explains the significance of the claims he's making.
i guess what i'm trying to say is that i read his comments and i didn't cry, which for me, at this late date, is a victory. beyond that, i don't have much more positive news to report. and i realize that i may be getting on the your nerves with all the neurosis and, as t.h.church says in sideways, "comedown bullshit." will try to be mindful of that, etc.
best cure is better writing.
No comments:
Post a Comment